Sunday, November 9, 2014

The Philippine General Hospital: An American Colonial Building Incorporating Filipino Cultural Values





Figure 1: An illustration of Philippine General Hospital’s Frontal Façade.

In 1907, the US-Philippine commission had appropriated a sum of P780,000 to build a hospital along Calle Rizal (or what is known today as Taft Avenue). The consulting architect, William Parsons, had already designed and built buildings in the Philippines such as the Philippine Normal School (1901) along Ayala Boulvard in Manila, the Mansion house (1908) in Baguio City, and the early campus of the University of the Philippines Manila (1908). By 1909, a central administration building, various wards and operating rooms and an out clinic for the hospital had been built. On September 1, 1910, the hospital, which was to be known as the Philippine General Hospital, was completed and opened to the general public. (Philippine General Hospital History, n.d) (See Figure 1 above)

While Wikipedia describes the Architecture of Philippine general Hospital as Neo-classical in style, the hospital’s stylistic design can be argued to be more of a simplified example of Spanish Colonial Revival Architecture (with inspiration from the existing Philippine architectural tradition), which was a United States architectural style movement popular between the 1915 and 1931 and was based on the Spanish colonial architecture of old Spanish cities in the Americas. (Architectural Styles in Palo Alto, n.d)

As seen in the frontal façade of the hospital, Parson’s design of PGH had stayed faithful to the preexisting Philippine Spanish colonial architectural tradition found in Manila, for both aesthetic and functional reasons. Large spans of smooth pastel-colored plaster wall, simple in design with almost no form of ornamentation, compose both the interior and exterior of PGH. Low pitched clay tiled roof with long eaves to provide shade for the walls of the building, also typical in the existing Spanish colonial architecture, was adopted in the roof design of PGH. Parson had agreed with Burnham’s idea that there was a particular “picturesque quality” of local Spanish architecture that should be maintained and should be “taken as examples of future structures” for their “beauty and practical suitability to local conditions” to which Parson thoroughly considered in the design of PGH. (Hines, 1932)



In various secluded sections and facades of PGH both in the interior and exterior, Parson also made use of decorative iron grill work/trim, small porches and tall double-hung sash windows for the design of the hospital (See Figure 2 & 3). This design choice may have taken inspiration from the practical function of ventilation and aesthetic look/ornamentation of ventanas and ventanilas of local Spanish architecture (such as the Bahay na Bato). It is important to note that the numerous large double-hung windows and open porches which connect the exterior environment and interior environment of the hospital not only provide for better cooling and ventilation in the tropical heat, but may also signify the Filipino value of of having a sense of openness and sociability. For example, during the Spanish colonial period, Filipinos would open the tall ventanas of their bahay na bato homes in the mornings to the noise and activities happening in the street below and at times, would even take part in social and business activities from his/her vantage point.

Figure 2 & 3: To the left small porches and iron grill work of PGH. Bottom left: The numerous large double hung windows used in the design of PGH. 


Parson was also notable for his use of the unique local architectural tradition of using Capiz shell on the sash windows of his buildings, such as PGH, to allow soft light to enter the interior while also preventing the glare of the sun as seen in the 2nd floor windows of Figure 1.





From top left going to right: Figure 4: An aerial view of PGH. Figure 5: An illustration of one of numerous patio within PGH.  Figure 6: Pathway leading to interior courtyard. Figure 7: Green space in interior courtyard of PGH.

Numerous inner courtyards with fountains (and the addition of green spaces) are found in PGH (See aerial view of PGH in Figure), and are reflective of the plaza in various Spanish towns during Spanish colonial era as the design of PGH’s structure is oriented inwards to these areas (See Figures 4-7 above). The easy access to these numerous and large spaces by users of the hospital generally reflect Burnham’s idea of City Beautiful movement, which pushed for providing more public spaces. These courtyards connected to open-air corridors also allow for better ventilation and cooling.

The choice of including these spaces in the design of PGH also shows Parson’s consideration of Filipino values of being close to nature due to the numerous green areas of these spaces, of taking strolls and walks (practiced during Spanish colonial period the as evidenced by bay where rich Filipinos would take afternoon carriage rides) and of the close relationship between internal and external environments for social reasons mentioned earlier.










Figure 8 & 9: Top left, an example of the shaded arcade of PGH. Top right: Profiles of the numerous arches used in the design of the hospital.

Perhaps the most recognizable features of PGH would be the long broad arches, and the shaded arcades and corridors (See Figure 8 & 9 above) connected to inner patios and courtyards where patients can wait and stroll around. Like the function of the large ventana-inspired windows of PGH, these open-air areas allow for better ventilation and cooling in the hospital and provide for natural lighting. (Hutchinson, 2010) The stylistic decision to design these arcades and corridors the way they are is conventional in Spanish Colonial Revival Architecture and in the design of various local government Spanish colonial buildings which Parsons took inspiration from. Filipino values of openness/sociability, of closeness to nature, and of taking leisurely walks are again reflected in this design choice of creating particularly open spaces with sparse physical barriers.



Figure 10 & 11: To the left, the frontal façade of PGH featuring its triangular pediment. To the right, a perspective of the main lobby of PGH.
Despite the meticulous faithfulness of Parsons in designing PGH based from local Spanish colonial architectural traditions, Parson also included in his design, neoclassical and Beaux-arts elements such as Triangular Pediment situated in the front façade of the hospital, the general design of the lobby of PGH (See Figure 10 & 11 above). American policy of colonization in terms of architecture was generally based off ideas of Burnham regarding the City Beautiful movement (1890s-1900s). The movement borrows elements from both the grandiose Beaux-Arts and Neoclassical styles in order to emphasize a sense of order, diginity and harmony as a way of creating societal moral. However, in the design of PGH, these styles were dramatically simplified as compared to City Beautiful-influenced structures in Chicago and Washington, for example, and were limited to the design of the traingular pediment (which contains no form of relief common to such in neoclassical architecture) and the interior of various main public areas such as the lobby of PGH (See Figure and above). For the most part, Parson’s design leans more towards a “Philipinized” Spanish colonial revival architecture.

This is not to say that the City Beautiful movement’s goals of creating a sense of order, dignity and harmony were not achieved. (Hines, 1932)  Parson’s faithfulness to local existing Spanish colonial architecture for both its beauty and suitability to local conditions (i.e. climate and Filipino values), while combing certain modern stylistic elements and construction methods to the design of PGH, in a metaphorical way achieves these goals in the context of Philippine Society.

Text Sources:

·             Hutchison, R. (2010). Manila, Philippines . Encyclopedia of urban studies (p. 484). Thousand Oaks, Calif.: SAGE Publications.chttp://www.pastheritage.org/PAstyle.html
 ·             Architecture in Palo Alto. (n.d.). Architectural Styles of Palo Alto. Retrieved October 14, 2014, from http://www.pastheritage.org/PAstyle.html ·             About Us / History | Philippine General Hospital. (n.d.). About Us / History | Philippine General Hospital. Retrieved October 14, 2014, from http://www.pgh.gov.ph/en/about-us/history/ ·             Hines, T. (1932). The Imperial Facade: Daniel H. Burnham and American Architectural Planning in the Philippines. Pacific Historical Review, Vol. XLL. No. 1, 90(No 1), none in particular
Image Sources
·             Figure 1: https://www.flickr.com/photos/jermsest/2282931332/in/photolist-dH4k1Q-7Leqrq-7XA7iP-dUpi9n-6KEqL2-7NGYM3-c8djYb-bu1bwH-8eHAYu-7mV46c-9jeFBZ-9jhNhE-9jhMFb-9jeFWR-9jeFLT-dPWfUo-7mV3Lk-8z3Bmu-4qUKAQ-DXuXP-8wfVC4-48jBqn-nD8bgM-c8dk2f-4eVDpG-7mV3x4-7mYX4w-631MwY-631kcA-62W1Pz-631nSs-631oYS-631C1o-dXfm19-4B3xo-a6aGEj-eAKkoU-4tJBX3-8VAT7i-ebPABa-aUAqNK-a6bug7-8HcPGJ-apC5os-fGWXL-ahZHSa-nDfuQp-nVJ6kz-ds4Nom-9tY143
·             Figure 2: https://www.flickr.com/photos/43095362@N00/3888657238/in/photolist-ax8h9t-jotJ2v-jowVSQ-axaZcy-jowVxw-9CeTZ5-kZrvQx-b8NzYR-5hADG6-kVJGNc-jmX2AY-7Ne5Y1-jmUFFQ-aU8b5p-jsx1ao-aDkp3c-9EGdYr-dVwny1-dVqMhi-8ZTZ2u-5hADKM-5hADQH-dVwngd-6Vyjjz-6VCoQm-7wiife-6VCojs-7wiifR-6VyjaB-6VyjGF-6VykiV-7wiifK-6Vyk1c-6VCprm-7wn9F7-6VyiUH-6Vykt2-6Vykbz-6VCpkW-7wiifD-7wiifT-6VCpAy-6VCoEd-4nnGct-7RFKgb-7RCrUV-7RCjmX-7RFD8Q-4VrwLT-7RCr7e
·             Figure 3: https://www.flickr.com/photos/43095362@N00/3887866667/in/photolist-6VykiV-7wiifK-6Vyk1c-6VCprm-7wn9F7-6VyiUH-6Vykt2-6Vykbz-6VCpkW-7wiifD-7wiifT-6VCpAy-6VCoEd-4nnGct-7RFKgb-7RCrUV-7RCjmX-7RFD8Q-4VrwLT-7RCr7e-7RCrAZ-7RCiRD-7RFCDy-7RFJg9-7RCkQT-7RCsc2-7RCrfv-7RFHjw-7RFLMC-7RFwPA-7RFAGE-7RFxmy-7RCuP2-7RFxUW-7RCpd4-7RFKX5-7RFLWC-7RCjF8-7RCvFB-7RFFms-7RCuae-7RCnq2-7RCooc-7RFBrG-7RFAZY-7RChsR-7RFHD7-7RFHvo-7RFEHW-7RFyNY
·             Figure 4: http://www.imagesphilippines.com/viewimage.php?id=798
·             Figure 5: http://www.lougopal.com/manila/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Interior_Philippine_General_Hospital.jpg\
·             Figure 6: https://www.flickr.com/photos/43095362@N00/3888658384
·             Figure 7: https://www.flickr.com/photos/43095362@N00/3887864623/in/photolist-6VyjGF-6VykiV-7wiifK-6Vyk1c-6VCprm-7wn9F7-6VyiUH-6Vykt2-6Vykbz-6VCpkW-7wiifD-7wiifT-6VCpAy-6VCoEd-4nnGct-7RFKgb-7RCrUV-7RCjmX-7RFD8Q-4VrwLT-7RCr7e-7RCrAZ-7RCiRD-7RFCDy-7RFJg9-7RCkQT-7RCsc2-7RCrfv-7RFHjw-7RFLMC-7RFwPA-7RFAGE-7RFxmy-7RCuP2-7RFxUW-7RCpd4-7RFKX5-7RFLWC-7RCjF8-7RCvFB-7RFFms-7RCuae-7RCnq2-7RCooc-7RFBrG-7RFAZY-7RChsR-7RFHD7-7RFHvo-7RFEHW
·             Figure 8: https://www.flickr.com/photos/xypotecka/4281010443/in/photolist-7wiifT-6VCpAy-6VCoEd-4nnGct-7RFKgb-7RCrUV-7RCjmX-7RFD8Q-4VrwLT-7RCr7e-7RCrAZ-7RCiRD-7RFCDy-7RFJg9-7RCkQT-7RCsc2-7RCrfv-7RFHjw-7RFLMC-7RFwPA-7RFAGE-7RFxmy-7RCuP2-7RFxUW-7RCpd4-7RFKX5-7RFLWC-7RCjF8-7RCvFB-7RFFms-7RCuae-7RCnq2-7RCooc-7RFBrG-7RFAZY-7RChsR-7RFHD7-7RFHvo-7RFEHW-7RFyNY-7RCtvR-7RFF49-7RFzzo-7RCn2g-7RCni4-7RChD6-7RCmhT-7RFHYq-7RFL7G-7RCj5g
·             Figure 9: http://www.lougopal.com/manila/wp-content/uploads/2013/08/Interior-PG-Hospital.jpg
·             Figure 10: https://www.flickr.com/photos/lulotruiz/12051031074
·             Figure 11: https://www.flickr.com/photos/doctony/279773889/

No comments:

Post a Comment